← Back to Index

WHO SAYS, “GOD IS NOT GREAT?”

Trinity Cathedral
The Rev. Canon Grant S. Carey

A recent book entitled God is Not Great is now on the bestseller list. It is one of several books written this year that are critical of religious faith especially as perceived and practiced in America. And while some might be shocked at my opinion about this - - I believe that they have good reason to believe they way they do!

Of the Puritans in Seventeenth-Century New England who, in the name of God, executed “witches” and pried into the daily lives of people, fearful that “someone, somewhere, might be happy.” - - of them it has been said, “their religion was cracked and crazy.”

The same might be said of a religion today that stands in contrast to the ideas of our founding Fathers who were well aware of what happened when religion dominated politics. Religious wars in Europe lasted hundreds of years and were centered not only in ideology but also in a quest for power. They knew that even the noblest form of religious idealism could be politically manipulated. Thus, while affirming moral values, they succeeded in separating secularized religion from government.

As Episcopalians, we affirm that God is Great. So did the first Christians who made converts in pagan Rome by expressing love and concern for one another. While writings as “God is Not Great” reflect an antipathy toward neo-fundamentalism and its quest for political power, we sadly must accept that our own beloved Anglican Communion threatens to divide over issues rather than celebrate and affirm what has been central to our being for centuries: diversity and the middle way.

For me, the greatest proponent of the middle way was Elizabeth I who, in the Sixteenth Century, inherited a kingdom bitterly divided over political and religious issues. Her genius lay in her ability to seek compromise rather than division; to find and hold fast the middle way that has been at the heart of Anglicanism for ensuing centuries. In spite of differences in language and culture, Anglicans throughout the world have preached moderation and the practical, prayerful solution to problems, whether social or theological. Because God IS Great, I am convinced that reason will prevail.

While Trinity Cathedral may not greatly influence the faith of men and women living in a pluralistic society, we must continue to do what we do quite well. First, to determine to work together in unity, whether or not we agree on all issues. Second, to make every effort to understand - - and even celebrate - - our differences. And third, to affirm by our daily lives that God IS Great!

Being Episcopalians and members of Trinity Cathedral is an affirmation that God IS Great! So also is seeking the middle way while doing everything in our power to respect the dignity of every human being, and (in the words of the Book of Common Prayer) “to follow Christ; to come together week by week for corporate worship; and to work, pray, and give for the spread of the Kingdom of God. (Page 856)